Another independent film release by Magnolia, The War Within appears to have more potential then the past independent releases I have reviewed. Critically acclaimed and nominee of several independent film awards, The War Within appears to be promising.

The film begins with Hassan, a Pakistani engineering student, walking through the streets of Paris who is then apprehended by western intelligence services for suspicion of terrorist activities. It becomes apparent that Hassan had no connection with terrorism, rather was brought in for questioning based on his brothers exploits as an activist. After being tortured for quite some time and sharing a cell with a terrorist, Hassan undergoes a radical transformation, turning himself into a terrorist. Hassan sneaks into America where the initial attack of his terrorist cell is foiled, and all but one of his brotherhood is arrested. The two regroup and plan to continue there terrorism when the heat dies down, Hassan relies on the hospitality of an old friend, where he stays and undergoes a self identification crisis. After becoming close once again with his friend Sayeed and his family, it becomes very difficult for Hassan to decide whether or not to undergo his plan to attack New York City.

This film offers a different kind of view on terrorism, from a terrorist himself, at times I think they too empathetically portray him, but not to the extreme. As the movie carries out Hassan speaks his propaganda to Sayeed’s family, which he feels very passionately about and rightfully so based on his experiences with Americans. But ultimately he doesn’t appear to be that bright, because instead of political means or protests he seems to think that killing more innocent people and himself will make things better. But before I get into a political debate here with myself I will point out that this is just a movie, one that offers some social commentary on the fear of terrorism and the fear of loosing our freedoms.

The War Within isn’t anything special, and is at times even very dull. However one scene was particularly interesting, that is when Hassan tries explaining the motives being terrorism to a child, which really puts things into perspective. I won’t comment on what I thought of his explanation, but it really puts his point of view into perspective and helps us understand the motives behind these unthinkable acts of terrorism. There is no way to justify terrorists actions and there never will be, but this movie comes as close as you can to explaining what motivates these people, and does a decent job of it.

Ultimately, The War Within wasn’t anything special, it had a pretty slow pace and wasn’t thrilling at all like it claims to be. But with that being said it offers some interesting commentary on one of the world’s touchiest issues, and if you enjoy that sort of thing then this movie is an interesting look on the other side of the coin.

Video

The War Within is presented in a 1080p 1.78:1 aspect ratio and offers a good video presentation from Magnolia. The first few minutes are filmed in heavy grain and soft picture, this is clearly the director’s intent but never the less I was concerned when I first saw this. Luckily the film cleans up past these scenes. Colors look rich and vibrant, especially the meet scene in the strip club, which showcase some impressive purples and blues. Facial detail was somewhat flat when up close but other details looks consistently sharp throughout. The problem I had with the transfer were the dirty and soft interrogation scenes scattered throughout the film. They are so bad in quality and frequent enough to really become somewhat annoying. Still, The War Within is a good looking title, although it is the weakest looking Magnolia release I have had a chance to review.

Audio

Magnolia has included both 5.1 Dolby Digital and DTS tracks, a nice touch they have been doing frequently with BD releases. As one might expect the film is completely dialogue and relies heavily on the front channels. Luckily it all sounds good with no dropouts and even adds a few subtle effects from the rear channels. Certain scenes like the Eid celebration offer some descent effects from the rear channel and sub, which was nice to hear. The War Within is no doubt a front heavy track, however the frequent enough use of rear channels and bass keep it from falling completely flat.

Special Features

All we get here is an Audio Commentary by Writer/Director Joseph Castelo and Writer/Actor Ayad Akhtar.

Final Thoughts

If you’re into terrorist movies then this is an interesting and very serious look into the mind of a conflicted, once innocent man. If that doesn’t sound like something you would be interested in, then avoid this movie. The video was average as well as the audio, so don’t expect anything spectacular from it, nor the special feature which is simply a commentary from the writers. If you have seen this movie and enjoy it then go ahead and pick up a copy, otherwise I wouldn’t suggest purchasing it, it’s a bit of an acquired taste.

Special Features List

• Audio Commentary